I bought three, one for myself, my wife, and my mother. For myself I didn't like the sponge it wasn't what I needed, not porous enough to really get the eyeshadow completely off the brush and it got filled up quickly between uses so clean up would be much more frequent then other brands like my old Sephora color switch. That being said my wife and mother loved it they have no complaints so far. The packaging is beautiful and the sponge with the little heart was cute. And when the sponge says it's final goodbyes you can repurpose the tin for something else.