this is a second review for the first 18 days that i have had this bundle. the eyeshadows apply beautiful, they do not smudge, they are not patchy, they are very resistent at removing them and in rain they resist quite a bit. the shimmers are out of this world! the quality is up there the price is awsome and the color story is very versatile and they work quite a bit together, even if they do not seem to.you will not loose money buying from oden's eye. i say this by having my own eyeshadow collection (40 eyeshadow pallets taken this year). try them out